Scoring...

Technical Criteria | Content Criteria | Design Criteria

Award Sites! Level 4.5

"...the difference between a bookmark and a 10-second visit."

MONITOR COLORS

of Web Users

---------------

 65,536 colors 16-bit 50.0%
16 mill. colors 32-bit 23.8%
16 mill. colors 24-bit 11.0%
256 colors 8-bit 6.4%
16 colors 4-bit 0.2%
4 colors 2-bit 0.04%
Not Specified 8.6%

Source: WebSnapshot.com 2001

MONITOR RESOLUTION

of Web Users

---------------

 800x600 50.4%
1024x768 28.5%
640x480 6.3%
1280x1024 3.3%
1152x864 2.7%
Not Specified 8.7%

Source: WebSnapshot.com 2001

Design Criteria

Presentation

Your site opens quickly and your message is clear and complete. But how it looks often represents the difference between a bookmark and a 10-second visit. A critical self-exam is necessary. Ask yourself a few questions:

  • Does the site truly represent you and your message?

  • Regardless of what you have seen elsewhere, is your site pleasing to visit…or painful to the eye?

  • Have you added elements simply because you could?

  • Did you rely on pre-formatted templates that give your site the same look as thousands of others?

Great sites don’t have to be hand-coded anymore. Beautiful results can be accomplished with dozens of web-authoring tools. How those tools are used is most important here.

Layouts should be clean and original in feel with an effective use of colors, fonts and graphics. While navigation is evaluated on its technical merit, it may also represent a design feature. As such, it should retain a consistency throughout the site. Sites featuring the latest technology like Flash, should exhibit more than a simple “gee whiz” factor…many of the current examples are little more than complex animated gif’s. Once again, is it there simply because you finally mastered an animation sequence, or does it contribute to the experience of the user?

Optimizing your graphics has multiple benefits. Above all, it allows the user to see your images more quickly. There is a limit, however. Over-optimization can destroy the visual integrity of an image. Programs like Photoshop and others readily available on the Web accomplish the task easily and seamlessly. Add the word "Wilton" in the Code box on the submission form.

And finally, there’s a better than average chance that we will still find the information we want without a pulsing red-on-green or spinning icon. There’s also a better than average chance that we won’t if we see an “Under Construction” sign. We already assume your site is a constantly evolving property…and probably doesn’t need these in any case.

Presentation Scoring:

Design

0-5 points are available for each

Overall “Look & Feel” (visually appealing)

Layout (effective use of design elements like tables, layers, borders, style sheets, etc.)

Colors (effective use of Web-safe colors to enhance the overall presentation)

Fonts (effective and consistent use of fonts that contribute to readability, impact and originality plus cross-platform compatibility)

Artistic Quality (original design elements that provide a consistent thread across the entire site)

Integration (elements of the design are in harmony – if present, effective use of plug-in elements like Flash or Shockwave enhance the presentation – sight and sound are appropriate to the design and subject matter)

Penalties

Three points are deducted for each

“Under Construction” signs

Flashing/blinking text or icons

Individual graphic elements that exceed 20k (optional downloads where size is noted not penalized.)

Scripts that graphically change pointers or create pointer trails within the content well
No access to “skip intro” on Flash presentations
Horizontal scrolling at screen resolutions of 800x600 or greater
Long pages that require more than three full scrolls at screen resolutions of 1024x768

 

Continue to Judges Profile

introduction | awards | criteria | judges

winners | privacy | resources | ethics

email

Email with any questions or if you need assistance.

Copyright © 2001-2002 by The Docherty Family of Wilton, CT. All rights reserved.